The Presbyterian Church voted recently to permit openly gay men and women to be ordained as members of the clergy, making it the fourth U.S. Protestant denomination to do so.
The deciding vote was cast by the Twin Cities Presbyterian church at a vote of 205 to 56 (with three abstentions). This made
Twin Cities the 87th presbytery to support the new policy on openly gay clergy, that was introduced last summer by the national assembly, Star Tribune said.
Under the rules of the church, a majority of the total of 173 presbyteries in the U.S. must vote to support new policies by the national assembly prior to its final approval. While 87 presbyteries agreed with the new policy, which takes effect on July 10, some 62 other presbyteries disapproved of it.
With the new rules, the Presbyterian Church (USA) which has up to three million members, will allow the ordination of openly gay members to serve as elders and deacons as well, Reuters said.
Near tears
Rev. Timothy Hart-Anderson, founder of Covenant Network of Presbyterians and pastor of downtown Minneapolis’ Westminster Presbyterian told Star Tribune, “It’s very exciting. I found myself welling up with tears.”
Hart-Anderson told Star Tribune, “Up until now they’ve had to be closeted. Now they’ll be able to come out. It will honor them as individuals and as full human beings like anyone else serving the church.”
Not everybody is happy with the new policy. Peter Hwang of Korean Presbyterian Church told Star Tribune, “It’s very unfortunate we have to have this discussion today. I think we should be ashamed of ourselves. This homosexual issue is breaking our church. We need to abide by Scripture.”
The issue of the ordination of openly gay clergy had rendered sharp divisions in the Presbyterian Church in the last five years, with some 100 congregations leaving the denomination out of a total of 11,000 congregations, according to Reuters.
One issue cited by critics is the Presbyterian Church USA’s constitution, which stated that its clergy are required to live “in fidelity within the covenant of marriage between a man and a woman, or chastity in singleness,” Reuters said.
However, the new policy overrides this and re-casted the former language to simply saying that clergy are required to live “joyfully submitting to the Lordship of Jesus Christ,” Star Tribune said.
Other denominations that accept ordination of people in same-gender relationships are The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (the largest Lutheran group in the U.S.), The United Church of Christ (which also allows same-sex marriage), and the
Episcopal Church.
On the other hand, the country’s biggest mainline Protestant denomination, The United Methodist Church (with eight million members), continues to disallow ordination of openly gay clergy and is likely to continue to require celibacy for unmarried ministers, Star Tribune said.
With the present vote it is expected that a 2008 controversy over Rev. Erwin Barron, former associate pastor of Westminster Presbyterian church, should be resolved, according to Star Tribune.
Barron, who is now a professor at a college in San Francisco, caused a furor when in 2008 he married his gay partner. Critics said the act violated the church constitution.
Barron was acquitted by a panel with a 3-3 vote and retains his church credentials with the Twin Cities Area presbytery. It was largely thought that the ruling would be appealed, but with the adoption of the new policy, the issue is expected to become moot, Star Tribune said.

